Curating My Long Term Trains of Thought

…  some context here re how #curating long term #TrainOfThought’s   is part of the purposes our TDs

but cutting to the chase …

There is a annoying problem currently as mentioned in “(private thought)”  so what thought #SeriTD lands on after a bookmark deletion needs to be changed in some manner anyway.

I propose the following …

null When a thought is deleted from the bookmarks,  #SeriTD should navigate to the next thought (or room) in the bookmark stack, set its group at attention, change that address to  the browser address, and adjust the title accordingly.   That would make the #curating of my long term trains of thought be fast and effective … not to mention using the bookmarks more effectively to keep my attention on my long term goals.

Another similar kind of change that is needed is that if your are in a room and send a thought there to the back room or delete it, then you shoud end up on the very next thought in that room.  This is another reason that i loose my trains of thought here in this thinking domain.
#bookmarks #curating

cc nathan


  2. curating
  3. TrainOfThought
  4. SeriTD
  5. thanks
  6. kudos


Si says
Okay. Useful ideas there. You should mentograph tag it usefully.  

In any case, as you probably noticed, all my available time is being spent right now on proliferation, not TD internals. When domains proliferate, and batch update, effortlessly (and we are nearly there … mainly waiting on the Bozonitron now) then I can go back to TD internals. I don’t want to work on internals while there are systems all over the place that need manual updating.

Seth says

Seth says

i thought i did “mentograph tag it usefully” null

What did i miss?

Si says
I don’t see any mentograph tags still. I only see hashtags. Hence, I cannot network off the mentograph.

Seth says
like i said before … again and again … there is no difference.  you claim there is.  i claim for any practical purposes there is no difference. 

Si says
I looked at what you are asking for more carefully. That attention changes when a bookmark is deleted is something that must be fixed. It should not be happening. (nullnow fixed. The delete button handler was simply missing an e.preventDefault())
#SeriTD should never ever change attention unexpectedly. You are asking for sudden and unexpected things to happen to fit your own model of thinking. How you think is extremely different from how I think. My bookmarks have no sequential relationship to each other at all. If the thought I am looking at suddenly changes just because I notice and delete some old bookmark I am no longer using, I would be extremely annoyed at having to go find my thought again. The same goes for moving something to the back room. I don’t think like that. When I change the state of a thought, I am most often still working with that thought in it’s new state. There is no relation between what I am thinking and some random next thought in the group. I would forever have to be finding my thoughts I am thinking again and again just because #SeriTD sent me off somewhere else because I did something unrelated to changing where I am thinking.

The thought you are looking at should never change unless you do something that clearly selects another thought … and should never change to something totally random such as the next thing in an unorganized list or a randomly created next thought in a group. Such attempted automation would seriously confuse and confound nearly everyone except the one guy who happens to organize his thinking, lists, and newly created thoughts, in some personally relevant way. Like for instance, so apparently you only backroom a thought at the end of thinking it? I almost always backroom a thought first, then work with it. If backrooming a thought sends me elsewhere I would always be up shit creek without a paddle forever searching for those thoughts I thought I was thinking!

If you want features to help you think, then they need to be clear features that are easy to understand and expect by anyone, not built upon quirks in the existing system. And never ever should attention change unexpectedly by doing something seemingly unrelated to selecting attention … which is exactly what both of your feature requests do.

I can conceive of a next-under like feature being useful. Something like the “n” and “b” keys in CyberMind™. It could move you to the next thought in a list such as the last tag room you visited, or a search result, or possibly even your bookmarks if you happen to order them in some non-random way. But such a feature would need a clear way to be interacted with that is independent from actions that are not related to changing attention. 

Seth says
okay the fix made it work 100% better … #thanks → nathan

We all think differently … i should not need to adapt to your way … or you adopt to my way.   When i curate my bookmarks i am focusing on changeing my long term attentions … i usually does not happen when i am focusing on some other specific thought.    When i am curating i must click on some thought in my stack to see what it is  so i know whether to delete it or bookmark it again to the top of the list.  #SeriTD could have done that for me,  it would not have been “an unexpected change”, she would have just done what i will need to do anyway the very next minute.

Maybe at some point that could be a mode one could go in. 

but no matter … works fine now … #kudos → nathan

Si says
Your welcome. But you are not “adapting to my way”. There is a well accepted industry design principal for UI’s that says “only change attention explicitly”. The only exception being when where attention is at now is deleted or removed. We follow that well accepted and well thought out guideline, that’s all. It is not “automated” to my desire at all.

Early systems, even early Windows, had lots of these idealized automated attention changers. It became hell for users and eventually designers agreed, don’t do that! No matter who such automation is nice for, there will always be more for which it is hell. *And* there is always a way to make a feature that will do what you want instead of adding automation to non-explict attention changing features.

What you are probably really refering to when you say “adapting to my way” is completely different things, like the admin user account. Those things are not related to automation of non-explicit actions. And quite frankly, not in your business.

Seth says
well your “industry standard” way of doing things is just one way to do them … i don’t think we should adopt it as some kind of God here.   But In general i agree. 

There can be a connection between a thinking person and #SeriTD … usually the person leads … and he leads almost always.   But not letting her lead, where the person wants her to lead, should not be prohibited by some “industry standard” way of thinking. 

See Also

  1. Thought Well here i am back in this reality with 312 viewings related by tag "kudos".
  2. Thought [title (23251)] with 262 viewings related by tag "thanks".
  3. Thought RFD: The base domain from which we proliferate with 201 viewings related by tag "SeriTD".
  4. Thought Enforcement enacted. with 187 viewings related by tag "SeriTD".
  5. Thought Work on baby ... with 167 viewings related by tag "SeriTD".
  6. Thought How does blockchain go beyond what we already have in GCP ? with 139 viewings related by tag "thanks".
  7. Thought To upload mp3 files to Fillmore box 6300 with 128 viewings related by tag "kudos".
  8. Thought Why my trains of thought break ... with 124 viewings related by tag "SeriTD".
  9. Thought Sometimes SeriTD gets Starry Eyed with 113 viewings related by tag "SeriTD".
  10. Thought Go Mark! with 102 viewings related by tag "kudos".
  11. Thought SeriTD dreams, and dreams of boz. with 91 viewings related by tag "SeriTD".
  12. Thought 3 state logic with 90 viewings related by tag "thanks".
  13. Thought 2016C - FALL CD catalog production with 86 viewings related by tag "kudos".
  14. Thought Making up Others with 85 viewings related by tag "kudos".
  15. Thought Automatic vertical image sizes with 80 viewings related by tag "SeriTD".
  16. Thought REPORTER with 77 viewings related by tag "thanks".
  17. Thought Put the river in fastblogit with 73 viewings related by tag "SeriTD".
  18. Thought #TypeError with 71 viewings related by tag "SeriTD".
  19. Thought Cloud SQL charges this month with 62 viewings related by tag "SeriTD".
  20. Thought My bookmarks are ... with 55 viewings related by tag "bookmarks".
  21. Thought Internet with 55 viewings related by tag "seritd".
  22. Thought Game Level 1 (FOUNDATION) is complete. with 54 viewings related by tag "SeriTD".
  23. Thought Amazon's Buy Box Games with 52 viewings related by tag "kudos".
  24. Thought Fo Hammer popped up at the FBI today. with 43 viewings related by tag "kudos".
  25. Thought RFC: Planning sub domain growth for with 37 viewings related by tag "SeriTD".
  26. Thought Questions about group tag clouds ... with 35 viewings related by tag "SeriTD".
  27. Thought about: something said or asked here - comment 60870 with 28 viewings related by tag "SeriTD".
  28. Thought Pride & Thanks feel Good with 26 viewings related by tag "thanks".
  29. Thought about: Siri is dying. Long live Susan Bennett. - Typeform blog with 24 viewings related by tag "SeriTD".
  30. Thought Copy of - Who wants a Thinking Live domain? with 19 viewings related by tag "SeriTD".
  31. Thought Footer problem on individual page at with 19 viewings related by tag "kudos".
  32. Thought Beard Gauge with 19 viewings related by tag "thanks".
  33. Thought Announcing Ability to Better Express Ourselves with 19 viewings related by tag "SeriTD".
  34. Thought Meatloaf with 17 viewings related by tag "kudos".
  35. Thought Lovely tag cloud! with 16 viewings related by tag "kudos".
  36. Thought Bookmarks Love with 15 viewings related by tag "bookmarks".
  37. Thought Sweet Potato Fries with 13 viewings related by tag "thanks".
  38. Thought Something about tag room bookmarks doesn't work. with 13 viewings related by tag "SeriTD".
  39. Thought about: how it works - ideabuzz with 13 viewings related by tag "kudos".
  40. Thought Probably the most pertinant speech yet this century with 11 viewings related by tag "kudos".
  41. Thought OMG We are back in business ... with 11 viewings related by tag "kudos".
  42. Thought [title (21652)] with 8 viewings related by tag "SeriTD".
  43. Thought Hey Mark with 7 viewings related by tag "SeriTD".
  44. Thought about: Thinking Domains as Assistive Technology - comment 61170 with 7 viewings related by tag "seritd".
  45. Thought Bookmarks with 3 viewings related by tag "bookmarks".
  46. Thought SeriTD has a message for @seth and @mark. with 3 viewings related by tag "seritd".
  47. Thought automatic bookmarks and intentional bookmarks with 3 viewings related by tag "bookmarks".
  48. Thought open source javascript spreadsheet engine with 3 viewings related by tag "bookmarks".
  49. Thought Open Source Media - OSM with 2 viewings related by tag "bookmarks".
  50. Thought Rules Engines with 2 viewings related by tag "bookmarks".