Burningbird ? I love you 25% of the time

source: my comment

I am ashamed and sad to report that i have never discovered an useful fact through an RDF inference. Oh sure, i have seen RDF inferences demonstrated academically ? but i am talking about a fact that i actually used for some purpose which was unknown except that it was uncovered by inference from an automated RDF processor. Has anyone? Can they document how the fact was discovered and how it was actually used.

? if not, is RDF inference not one of the biggest snow jobs ever perpetrated on the web?


...

Tags

  1. rdf
  2. inference
  3. burningbird
  4. my comments
  5. logic

Comments


Seth says
after Dan pointed to foaf smushing i needed to clarify
source: my comment
Actually, Dan and Shelley, i was looking not for an application like foaf where smushing is necessary ... but rather a real example of someone actually finding something that they were looking for and where the fact that they found was inferred and not just typed into a ground fact. Such an real example might look like ... one 3/2/2006 i needed to find a friend of Dan Brinkley who was attending SWSX and was flying from SEA on flight 239, so i just went to my laptop and typed in this query (provided) and came up with Susie Q who i talked with on the flight. Also, please note that you can't just make it up ... it had to really happen ... and sufficient documentation should be provided so that we can fisk it.
...



Mark de LA says
Is this what the old man meant when he said "Go fisk yourself !" ? I have been unable to understand his use vis-a-vis the new definition in accordance with the Wikipedia. The closeness of the old man's use of the word to the Norwegian word for fish may have confused me .


Seth says
... Shelley's reaction is to send me the bill
source: my comment
Shelley, my point is that if RDF inference maps to the null set of practical real world examples, then why spend so much time on it ? rather concentrate on RDF as a medium to record ground facts. I?ve posed this challenge before and nobody has ever met the challenge. If this were a practical thing, these examples would be as common as ass holes. Doesn?t that make your think ? it does me? i mean how many years has RDF Inference been around and still nobody has gotten anything real out of it. And no, LOL, I?m not going to pay you for it ? rather i would require such an example out front before i decided to invest in this vaporal notion.

Mark de LA says
source: ... I think the problem is with logic itself, there just is no way to maintain identity sufficient for useful inference in the wild west of the web period.
... Is this just another logic tirade or are you saying something else ?


Seth says
M 2006-05-01 13:25:45 3440
Maybe, there is just NOT enough of a critical mass of RDF users & providers around to make it practical. I'm sure that big-G didn't start off with a billion webpages when it was first noticed. I'm neither pro nor con, really!  I'm sure there are a few people who could ask "why should I blog & tag my items on fbi when del.icio.us or technocrati has a bigger market ?" and "Has anyone ever found something useful on fbi that they didn't know was there in the first place ?" - i'ts evolution man ! Survival is better said the ....

I think that if a process works,  there will be early examples which prove the concept ... then if it scales, the more people use the process, the more examples pop out.  Lots of people are using RDF now, but nobody (that i know of) has reported discovering information via inference ... no proof of concept has been reported.  Oh sure, lots of researchers have demonstrated examples of inference where they setup all the circumstances and got the correct result ... i mean Tim Berners-Lee's CWM was all the craze several years ago... and it can generate inferences ... but nobody uses these inferences.  Instead, were they to get information out of their RDF stores, they just retrieve the ground facts that were input using SPARQL ... and were we to ask for real world examples of such usage, those examples would show up.

I think the problem is with logic itself, there just is no way to maintain identity sufficient for useful inference in the wild west of the web period.

Seth says
M 2006-05-02 09:34:24 3440
source: ... I think the problem is with logic itself, there just is no way to maintain identity sufficient for useful inference in the wild west of the web period.
... Is this just another logic tirade or are you saying something else ?

we are looking for real world examples where inference worked ... not philosophysing about logic. Forget about RDF ... provide a documented example (see what it might look like above) of where binary inference was used to arrive at a fact that was used ... make sure to include documentation for fisking.

Ravi says
Well, i built a RDf based system, actually a company. it works...when i hear RDF doesn't work, mostly it is a user error. wrong application of the tool. its works well when one has various data types and application using them have difficulty in keeping up with various data types.

RDF inference engine won't solve world's hunger. but in a closed system, could be a very complex, big system like networking - it can turn up interesting results. i have lived it.

See Also

  1. Thought BARBARA CUBED - The Manual of Pure Logic with 270 viewings related by tag "logic".
  2. Thought Comparison Of California As Island to Google Earth with 269 viewings related by tag "my comments".
  3. Thought Conversation on hash tags? with 111 viewings related by tag "logic".
  4. Thought 3 state logic with 90 viewings related by tag "logic".
  5. Thought List of Logical Fallacies with 67 viewings related by tag "logic".
  6. Thought The binary logic of two distinctions with 36 viewings related by tag "logic".
  7. Thought What if there were no stars? with 26 viewings related by tag "burningbird".
  8. Thought Identity Entails Logic with 22 viewings related by tag "logic".
  9. Thought The Rise of Gobbledygook. with 18 viewings related by tag "logic".
  10. Thought BARBARA CUBED - I. DEFINITIONS with 17 viewings related by tag "logic".
  11. Thought about: oreilly.com -- Online Catalog: What Are Syndication Feeds, First Edition with 14 viewings related by tag "burningbird".
  12. Thought JasonLd with 14 viewings related by tag "rdf".
  13. Thought Calling for an end to all of this negativity ... with 10 viewings related by tag "burningbird".
  14. Thought Identity Entails the Laws of Logic with 10 viewings related by tag "logic".
  15. Thought I Demand An Apology with 9 viewings related by tag "my comments".
  16. Thought Quads with 8 viewings related by tag "my comments".
  17. Thought Naming Context with 8 viewings related by tag "rdf".
  18. Thought War On Christmas with 7 viewings related by tag "my comments".
  19. Thought phrases are more specific than single words with 7 viewings related by tag "logic".
  20. Thought Truth with 7 viewings related by tag "logic".
  21. Thought about: Microsoft Team RSS Blog : Icons: still orange with 7 viewings related by tag "burningbird".
  22. Thought about: Aljazeera Cartoons with 6 viewings related by tag "my comments".
  23. Thought allow authors to sell access to items with 6 viewings related by tag "my comments".
  24. Thought about: google open source blog: cayley: graphs in go with 6 viewings related by tag "rdf".
  25. Thought The Ten Commandments of Logic with 6 viewings related by tag "logic".
  26. Thought The Rest Of The Story with 6 viewings related by tag "burningbird".
  27. Thought Mr President, to surge or not to surge ? with 6 viewings related by tag "my comments".
  28. Thought about: logically speaking with 6 viewings related by tag "logic".
  29. Thought Why quads? Quads vs RDF with 6 viewings related by tag "rdf".
  30. Thought Illative force with 6 viewings related by tag "logic".
  31. Thought about: How to Talk to a Sceptic about Global Warming with 6 viewings related by tag "my comments".
  32. Thought Hezbollah's Propoganda is Distorting Media Coverage with 6 viewings related by tag "my comments".
  33. Thought What is the mentography of JSON ? with 6 viewings related by tag "rdf".
  34. Thought about: Google Help : Add to Google button with 5 viewings related by tag "my comments".
  35. Thought life is gangly ... it hairs away from you with 5 viewings related by tag "my comments".
  36. Thought JavaScript based HTML editor with 5 viewings related by tag "my comments".
  37. Thought Privacy is antithetical to the semantic web with 5 viewings related by tag "burningbird".
  38. Thought Illative Force - A Lament with 5 viewings related by tag "logic".
  39. Thought Aristotle on Topics with 5 viewings related by tag "logic".
  40. Thought about: Niall Kennedy's Weblog: Microsoft Technology Preview with 4 viewings related by tag "my comments".
  41. Thought about: EconoMeta with 4 viewings related by tag "burningbird".
  42. Thought about: hmmm .... with 4 viewings related by tag "logic".
  43. Thought about: MindRaider - Semantic Web Outliner with 4 viewings related by tag "rdf".
  44. Thought Shelley says we look a lot like ... with 4 viewings related by tag "burningbird".
  45. Thought Pride an Glory in Your Code with 4 viewings related by tag "logic".
  46. Thought about: Search engine's sense of humour crashes as it fires off warning letters over use of name as a verb with 4 viewings related by tag "burningbird".
  47. Thought about: GW Document: Spring - #57 with 4 viewings related by tag "logic".
  48. Thought Extensional VS Intensional Logic with 4 viewings related by tag "logic".
  49. Thought A == A aka Indetity with 4 viewings related by tag "logic".
  50. Thought repeating data between domains with 4 viewings related by tag "burningbird".